Restaurant Hours

Monday - Friday 5:00a.m. to 3:00p.m

Saturday & Sunday: 5:00a.m. to 2:00p.m

Deli Hours

Monday - Friday 5:00 a.m to 3:00 p.m

Saturday & Sunday 5:00:a.m to 4:00p.m


317 Nora St. Stoughton, WI 53589

Restaurant: 608-873-9299

Deli : 608-646-0098

American Food Restaurant & Catering

The Sugar & Spice Eatery & Deli is a small, family owned restaurant serving home-style family cuisine. We pride ourselves in our excellent service and savory comfort food. The Eatery is a local, independently owned, and family run business, and we make it a point to be active in the Mentor community. So, come in for a visit and enjoy the satisfaction of supporting a local business, the friendly and caring service, and above all the delicious food!




Dear Carrie,

The purpose of this letter is a respone regarding a review of the quality of Sugar and Spice Eaterym Stoughon, WI For many years I have worked with the staff from Sugar and Spice eatery for catering purposes and for ordering food from that establishment for funeral arrangements, START banquets, and for parent groups that provide food to participants.  In every event, Sugar and Spice Eatery has provided excellent food and READ MORE

Places to Eat Stoughton WI
Places to Eat Stoughton WI
Places to Eat Stoughton WI


Home Cooking at it's best!

Fresh home made hot meals every day. Homemade soups and deserts.


Excellent food and excellent service.

The staff are friendly, flexible in considering the order that is provided, dependable in their delivery, and the food itself is outstanding.


Served all day!

This is by far the best breakfast spot in the area. The Eggs Beni is some of the best I have had! The hash browns are crispy & perfect. The service is top notch & fast.  We will be back!

Matt F.


Tastes that delight your appetite!

Freshly made pies, cakes and more.

Based in Stoughton WI, catering to Madison, Oregon, McFarland, Cambridge, Verona, Deforest, Middleton, Waunakee and the greater Dane County area.
Member of Stoughton WI Chamber Of Commerce

Sorry for the inconvenience but we do not accept Door Dash

© 2014 Sugar & Spice Eatery

Stoughton Chamber Of Commerce Member

  • w-facebook